Arts & Sciences

Momus: A Poem

by George Saville Carey 1743–1807

From Analects in Verse and Prose, vol. I (London, 1770)

Arts & Sciences

No more shall Monkey's mimicry engage;
No more shall Cats and Dogs usurp the stage,
See Momus' sons, a single unit higher,
Divert the town with their detractive fire,
While patents royal are to Merit thrown,
To please Sir Francis and a tasteless town.

See Foote the foremost of the mimic race,
Amuse the town with scandal and grimace;
While private characters each scene adorn,
Held up by him to meet the public scorn.

Where custom's brought on some peculiar mode
Of speech, or air, out of the common road;
If but deficient in a leg or eye,
Or, from misfortune, chance to look awry,
This maimed mimick, favour'd so by fate,
That he might still more truly imitate;
With self-vain zeal a stupid laugh to raise,
He with a low audacity conveys
His borrow'd puns, with a sarcastic face,
Join'd by the meanest of the acting race,
Without restraint his dearest friends expose,—
But Foote and friendship are eternal foes.

Never did folly, with such sway, maintain
Her seat, and, with her baby rattle, reign
Over Apollo and his laurell'd sons,
With glees and catches, mimicry and puns.
Like the loud quack, in some small country town,
Who, with his fool, entices ev'ry clown;
Displays his pranks, his filthy nostrums vends,
And, with a puff, their quality commends:
So Foote his own loud brazen trumpet blows,
And would, like him, his trash for wit impose:
As wrecks and rubbish follow ev'ry tide,
So ev'ry blockhead joins the laughing side.

Blest with a face of humour, to engage
At once a drooping, and a laughing age,
Shuter with some pretensions to a name,
Stands forth distinguish'd in the book of fame:
The grateful public will for humour take
Whatever blunder he may chance to make;
Who, fond of laughter, oddity and whim,
Have fix'd the mask of Comedy on him.

With face by Bacchus and by Venus marr'd,
For he with both the mighty powers warr'd;
In word expressive, and in gesture dry,
In action simple, with a meaning eye,
See Weston gravely force the hearty smile,
Nor pall with low buffoonery the while:
Whene'er in Sneak or Drugger he appears,
Garrick attends with patient eyes and ears,
And owns his humour natural and true,
For Garrick must give genius her due.

See Dibble Davis better half the year
A mere poltroon—a hero how appear!
Unnotic'd and obscure he struts unknown,
An utter stranger to the injur'd town,
'Till Foote, his patron, impotent and wise,
At once convinces each beholder's eyes,
That merit oft beneath oppression dwells,
For see how Davis now himself excells.
Aimwell, Cassio, nay, and many more,
Such parts were never acted so before,
And that my Muse may shew her meaning plain,
Hopes ne'er to see 'em murder'd so again.

An arrant stroller, from the lord knows where,
A true itinerant, now here, now there,
Who oft from barn to barn, from town to town,
Ten nights has labour'd for a single crown;
See Bannister assume (unaw'd by shame)
A mimic's vile and despicable name;
For Bannister a Wilkinson would be,
But can't so truly imitate as he.
To ape the manner of some better play'r,
An act ungen'rous, at the best, unfair;
Why should one actor villainously try
To damn another in the public eye?
Either by malice or by envy led,
To hurt his brother in his fame or bread?
When to the world 'tis evidently known,
He ne'er could boast a method of his own.
Such are a pest and scandal to the stage,
And who but Foote would any such engage?
For all must own the stage was ne'er design'd
To point at this, or that, but all mankind.
E'en devotees must own the stage of use,
Where it don't leave instruction for abuse.

Led by conceit, and fond of stage applause,
Yet stands condemn'd, if judg'd by acting laws;
With face, nor voice, nor action, to commend,
Or win one single auditor his friend;
See Sowden, great in capitals, appear,
Disgust the eye and grate the dullest ear;
For he most surely, of all human kind,
Was ne'er by nature for the stage design'd:
Long in Hibernia has he trod the field,
Where judgment oft to prejudice must yield,
And with no small indulgence and regard,
Tho' ev'ry night some noble part he marr'd.
See him return, declining, and in age,
Riding, his only Hobby-horse, the stage,
And with a boyish zeal the toy embrace,
Tho' time with years has wrinkled o'er his face.

Of vulgar accent, and of bully's pink,
A rolling sidle, with a knowing wink,
Coarse and robust, who might perhaps engage,
Had he been cast on the Broughtonian stage:
Palmer, self-confident, attempts to please,
In high wrote parts of elegance and ease;
But like to him, who roll'd the stone in vain,
Will ne'er the summit of his hopes attain;
Yet must we own him some small share of praise,
When Bruin, Loader, and such parts he plays;
He's sure to please while in this line he steers,
For in such parts he still himself appears.
Then let him ever in that track remain,
Where he is sure, some small applause to gain,
And never more in gentlemen and beaux,
Disgrace the stage, the author and the cloaths.

Barry, each season, might delight the town,
But that we've better actors of our own:
Yet think not, Barry, that I will disgrace,
Or mean to herd him with the common race;
He is an Actor ev'ry judge must own,
And long has prov'd the sav'rite of the town,
'Till Powell chanc'd within his walk to tread,
And pluck'd the blooming laurel from his head:
Yet in Othello must each actor yield,
There even Garrick must give up the field:
All own him for the part by nature fram'd,
And think of Barry when Othello's nam'd.

Not so thy son, when in each part he tries,
To copy thee, too oft from nature flies;
Yet will it faintly bear the name of fault,
To follow close the manners we are taught:
From thee, his ev'ry method he conceiv'd,
From thee, each beauty and each fault receiv'd,
Nor should we deem him destitute of art,
Did he with decency perform one part.

O could my ardent, yet unwilling muse,
Obtain one kind and plausible excuse,
And, without censure, be indulged to spare,
And overlook the errors of the fair—
But chaste Astrea guides my feeble hand,
And will not listen to my warm demand.

Blest with a form of elegance and ease,
Two requisites that must for ever please,
Who for a season might perhaps engage,
When Yates, awhile, retires from the stage:
See Dancer now each high-rate part possess,
And try to picture virtue and distress,
But judgment seems to leave her in the dark,
Whene'er she aims to hit the doubtful mark.

With bold presumption, in despite of shame,
Jefferies attempts to join the rank of fame,
And void of judgment, attitude and speech,
She aims at characters above her reach;
When poor Alicia with distraction raves,
And calls for racks, for thunderbolts, and graves;
Did Cinderilla ever scold so well,
When in her airs she bids you go to hell?
When drove by love and passion and despair,
And having lost all hopes, begins to swear;
So sad Alicia, when by Jefferies play'd,
A mere impetuous termagant is made.
Forgive me, Jefferies, if I speak my mind,
True satire never leaves one fault behind;
But since she's brought thy errors forth to view,
So shall she speak of thy perfections too.
In third-rate parts, where nature don't require
Such skill in action, or such force of fire,
When nor by pride nor by ambition led,
The paths of mediocrity you tread,
There, spite of censure, shalt thou justly raise,
The smile of pleasure and the voice of praise.

See one in parts of wit and humour, strive
To catch the manner of a Pope or Clive;
For Gardiner the copyist betrays,
In ev'ry part of humour that she plays,
And from her acting it is plainly shewn,
She likes their method better than her own;
But such, a barren genius declares,
Who, having no intention, borrows theirs.

Behind appear a despicable race,
Without one single requisite or grace,
Beneath the notice of my honest muse,
Who but to mention, would herself abuse.
Names both to genius and to fame unknown,
The needy stragglers of each country town;
Fit but to form some necessary group,
Or to compleat Foote's miserable troop,
When furnish'd out with truncheons and with cloaths,
See 'em a royal company compose.

By these enforc'd, and arm'd with impudence,
See him invade the boundaries of sense,
Break thro' the rules of judgment, wit, and taste,
And lay, with ridicule, their kingdoms waste;
Pleas'd with his own, behold the mocker strive,
With some success, his Grub-street to revive,
And ev'ry season palls us with the same,
'Till jaded patience sickens at his name.
Each man of candour must in this agree,
His merit lies in inconsistency:
Pleas'd with the promise of some joyous fun,
Away to Foote's the herd unthinking run:
He gains his riches at the fool's expence,
Despis'd and shunn'd by ev'ry man of sense.

High on Parnassus wou'd he wish to ride,
And, unrestrain'd, the winged courser stride;
But is it not most evident to all,
The limping Bard has had a fatal fall.
A famous play-wright wou'd he seem to be,
A very Phoenix to posterity.—
Grief! that his name must with his body die,
And all his bantlings with their father lie,
When, lacking his distortion and grimace,
Their sole protection and their only grace,
Spurn'd and detested in some wiser age,
Will never more get footing on the stage.

Of these, the Minor, at the head we see,
Born at the time of his necessity;
When threaten'd by the horrors of a jail,
Was forc'd to hoist up ev'ry tatter'd sail;
And must have sunk had not the tortur'd Cole,
(Who, like a pirate, he unjustly stole)
Buoy'd him, when sinking, to the welcome shore,
And sav'd at once his vessel and his store.

The Lyar too, his master-piece confess'd,
A very fustian-jacket at the best.

The Mayor of Garratt next we bring to view,
Which we must own both laughable and new,
But candour will admit of no excuse,
Where she beholds such personal abuse.

His Patron, Commissary, even all
His filthy drolls, beneath this censure fall.

His Orators, a very hodge-podge see,
Made up of rubbish and absurdity,
Cramm'd full of puns, of nonsense and parade,
With neither plot, or meaning to it's aid:
But while to wit he makes the least pretence,
Or tries to introduce one line of sense;
With vain attempt he stammers at the task,
A very Midas in Apollo's mask.

These grown quite thread-bare, and worn out with age,
Like Foote himself, a nuisance to the stage,
He's brought his Taylors, like a thrifty friend,
To botch their elbows and their linings mend;
Did Smithfield e'er produce a bill so rare,
When Punchinello was the hero there?
Did ever Flockton's tragedy excell?
Was ever shew-bill drawn up half so well?
Did ever quack with such parade engage?
Not even Rock when he adorn'd the stage:
Did Taylor e'er with patchwork form a coat,
And without measure too, as Foote has wrote?
Did ever play-wright exercise his quill
With half that humour, or with half that skill?
And stock'd, like him, with true poetic lore,
Write such a Taylor's tragedy before.

Try'd, and condemn'd by th' indulgent town,
The father won't his new-born idiot own:
But fain wou'd bribe the bawdy muse it's mother,
To lay the frightful monster on another.
Yet if with close inspection you shou'd trace
The striking outlines of the infant's face,
The father's strong resemblance you'll behold,
As die to die, cast in the self-same mould.

As Epicureans with luxuriant waste,
Who lose at once their appetite and taste,
And try to teaze the stomach ev'ry hour
With something sweet, or else with something sour;
Or when the rake is quite indiff'rent grown,
Sated with all the pleasures of the town;
See him from place to place with transport fly,
In search of pleasure in variety.
When sick of high life he begins to grow,
He tries to find a relish in the low;
Foote next arises to his vacant mind,
For there he's sure the simplest fare to find;
No heavy sentence to perplex the brain,
No searching morals on the mind remain,
But, like the froth, dissolving in the taste,
And, ere it meets the lip, begins to waste:
While in our ears he dins the mighty pother,
It enters one, and hurries out at t'other.

✦ ✦ ✦

Subtitle: "Or, a Critical Examination into the Merits of the Performers, and Comic Pieces, at the Theatre-Royal in the Haymarket."

MLA

Carey, George Saville. “Momus: A Poem.” Poetry Codex, poetrycodex.com/poem/carey_gs/9/.

Chicago

Carey, George Saville. “Momus: A Poem.” Poetry Codex. https://poetrycodex.com/poem/carey_gs/9/.

Read this poem with the Codex →

More by George Saville Carey